At One Nation Every Vote (OneV), we believe that understanding the history of voting rights in America is key to protecting and expanding those rights today. In our countdown of the OneV’s Top 20 Moments in American Voting History, we’re highlighting the pivotal events that have shaped our democracy. This week, we continue our series with moment #11: Smith v. Allwright (1944).
The Road to Smith v. Allwright
In the first half of the 20th century, African American citizens in the South faced deeply entrenched barriers to voting. One of the most significant of these was the all-white primary, a practice used by the Democratic Party in Southern states to exclude Black voters from primary elections. Because the Democratic Party was dominant in the South at the time, the real contests were often decided in the primaries—not the general elections—meaning Black voters were effectively shut out of the democratic process.
The legal basis for this exclusion rested on the idea that political parties were private organizations and could therefore set their own rules for participation, even if those rules violated the 15th Amendment’s guarantee that voting rights could not be denied on the basis of race.
Lonnie E. Smith, a Black voter from Texas, challenged this injustice. Represented by future Supreme Court Justice Thurgood Marshall and the NAACP Legal Defense Fund, Smith sued election official S.E. Allwright for denying him the right to vote in a 1940 Democratic primary in Harris County, Texas.
The Supreme Court Decision
In a landmark 8–1 decision issued on April 3, 1944, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Smith v. Allwright that the all-white primary was unconstitutional. The Court concluded that political parties, while technically private, were integral to the election process and therefore subject to the Constitution’s protections. The ruling overturned an earlier decision (Grovey v. Townsend, 1935) and established that racial discrimination in primary elections violated the 15th Amendment.
The Impact
Smith v. Allwright was a major breakthrough in the fight for civil rights and voter access. By dismantling the legal foundation of the all-white primary, the Court removed one of the most powerful tools of voter suppression in the South. The decision led to a wave of Black voter registration and political activism, laying the groundwork for future victories in the civil rights movement, including the Voting Rights Act of 1965.
However, the ruling also provoked backlash. Southern states quickly adopted new voter suppression tactics—such as literacy tests, poll taxes, and intimidation—which would continue to be challenged for decades. Still, Smith v. Allwright stands as a critical moment when the Supreme Court recognized and enforced the constitutional principle that no citizen should be denied a vote based on race.
Why This Moment Matters
Smith v. Allwright reminded the nation that democracy is not static. It requires vigilance, courage, and the willingness to confront injustice in all its forms. This case showed that legal victories can transform our electoral system and empower generations of voters.
Stay Tuned: Moment #10 Coming Next Week
We’re halfway through our countdown. Join us next week as we unveil Moment #10 in our Top 20 Moments in American Voting History—another powerful step toward a more inclusive democracy.
Take Action with OneV
If you believe in the power of nonpartisan education and the importance of protecting voting rights for all Americans, support One Nation Every Vote today. Your contribution helps us continue sharing these stories and expanding voter participation in elections at every level of government.
Donate now to be a part of this vital work.
Leave a Reply